Below you can see a short overview of different religions:
| religion | View on Surrogacy |
| Catholicism | Strongly opposes surrogacy, viewing it as immoral and a violation of the sanctity of marriage and procreation. Children should be conceived naturally by married couples. |
| Protestantism | Views vary widely; some denominations accept surrogacy as an act of compassion, while others oppose it due to concerns about third-party involvement. |
| Judaism | Generally accepts surrogacy as a solution for infertility, provided no harm is done. However, Orthodox Jews may oppose it, citing concerns about exploitation and lineage. |
| Islam | Opinions are divided; many Sunni scholars consider it unlawful, while Shia Islam may permit it under specific conditions. Surrogacy is often viewed through the lens of marital integrity. |
| Buddhism | Fully accepts surrogacy, as procreation is not seen as a moral obligation; infertility treatments are not considered immoral. |
| Hinduism | Allows surrogacy but prefers that both egg and sperm come from the married couple raising the child; generally supportive of fertility treatments. |
Read more: Can it be surrogacy-free?
Let’s talk about the above beliefs in more detail, to check everything that may stop you from deciding whether to have a baby through surrogacy or not:
Is surrogacy a sin in Christianity?
The question of whether surrogacy is considered a sin in Christianity does not have a straightforward answer. Views on this issue vary significantly among different denominations and individual believers.
-
Is surrogacy a sin in Catholicism?
The Roman Catholic Church strongly opposes surrogacy. According to their beliefs, surrogacy undermines the importance of marriage and the value of having children. The Church teaches that when a husband and wife are married, they should be the ones to have and raise their children. Many people believe that being a surrogate mother goes against the true responsibilities of motherhood and can violate the rights of a child, as it is thought that a child should be cared for by their biological parents.
Pope Francis has said that surrogacy is ethically wrong because it takes advantage of women and turns children into goods. The Catholic Church says that any method of reproduction that uses a third party, like egg or sperm giving or surrogate motherhood, is deeply wrong.
Read more: best surrogacy doctors in the world
-
Is surrogacy a sin in Protestantism?
In contrast, Protestant views on surrogacy are more diverse. Many Protestant denominations adopt a more liberal stance, allowing for individual interpretation of biblical principles regarding family building.
While some conservative groups may be against surrogacy because they think it is immoral, others see it as a good choice for couples who are having trouble getting pregnant. People often use the Bible story of Sarah and Abraham, in which Sarah offered her maid Hagar as a substitute for her child, as an example that can be taken in different ways.
In the end, a lot of Protestants think that strict religious rules shouldn’t affect their choice to use a surrogate. Instead, they think that personal conscience and prayer should be.
Read more: Independent Surrogacy
What are the church’s views on surrogacy?
The Orthodox Churches generally align with Catholic teachings, viewing surrogacy as inconsistent with traditional family values and the sanctity of marriage. They emphasize maintaining the unity of husband and wife in procreation and often express concerns about the ethical implications surrounding surrogacy arrangements. Like Catholics, Orthodox Christians are wary of how these practices can affect familial bonds and moral responsibilities
Open Dialogue:
Despite these differing views, many Christian communities encourage open discussions about the moral complexities surrounding surrogacy. Even though these things are different, many churches support open conversations about the moral issues surrounding surrogacy and urge couples who are thinking about this road to get pastoral help.
In summary, while the Catholic Church firmly opposes surrogacy based on its teachings about marriage and procreation, There is a wider range of views in Protestant denominations that can be used to fit different situations.
Orthodox churches often share Catholic beliefs and stress the importance of traditional family arrangements. All branches know that talking to each other and getting pastoral help is important for figuring out this complicated problem.
Read more: Countries where surrogacy is legal
Factors Leading to Acceptance of Surrogacy by Some Churches
The acceptance of surrogacy by certain churches depends on various factors, which may include the following:
1. Attention to Emotional and Physical Needs
Many churches focus on the emotional and physical needs of couples facing infertility challenges. These churches believe that surrogacy can serve as a solution to help these couples achieve their desire for parenthood.
2. Diverse Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Different interpretations of sacred texts can lead to the acceptance of surrogacy in some churches. Some Protestants may interpret biblical stories in a way that reflects flexibility regarding reproductive methods.
3. Humanitarian and Ethical Approach
Some churches believe that helping others and performing good deeds (such as surrogacy) should take precedence. This humanitarian approach can lead to viewing surrogacy as an ethical act that creates new life.
4. Dialogue and Counseling
Churches that emphasize dialogue and counseling may be more open to surrogacy, allowing couples to make informed decisions with spiritual and emotional support. This approach can create a safe space for discussing complex issues like surrogacy.
Read more: Best country for IVF in Asia
5. Focus on Women’s Rights
Some churches may emphasize women’s rights and choices, viewing surrogacy as a personal option for women. This perspective can contribute to the acceptance of surrogacy, especially if women can make this decision with full awareness and without social pressure.
6. Response to Social Changes
In light of social and cultural changes, some churches may adapt themselves to meet new societal needs and accept surrogacy as a viable option.
These factors illustrate the complexity of the topic of surrogacy within religious contexts, showing how attitudes can be influenced by social, cultural, and doctrinal conditions.
Read more: IVF in Iran
Surrogacy in Islam and Iran
In Islamic teachings, views on surrogacy also vary significantly. Ayatollah Khomeini permitted surrogacy under specific conditions: the child must be recognized as the biological child of the donor father. This perspective aligns with Islamic principles regarding lineage and parentage.
In Iran, where Shia Islam predominates, surrogacy has gained legal acceptance since laws were enacted in 2003 allowing fertility treatments that include artificial insemination and embryo donation.
However, many Sunni-majority countries continue to prohibit surrogacy altogether.
The differences in religious perspectives highlight the broader ethical debates surrounding reproductive technologies.
For Christians considering surrogacy, it is essential to weigh personal beliefs against denominational teachings while also considering the emotional and ethical implications involved in such decisions.
In conclusion, while some Christians may find ways to reconcile their faith with the practice of surrogacy, others may view it as incompatible with their beliefs. Ultimately, individuals are encouraged to seek guidance from their faith communities and engage in thoughtful reflection about their unique circumstances.
We answer the religious question “Can Christians do surrogacy?” and want you to know about all the things that may prevent people from trying to do everything being parents and creating hopeful families.
If your beliefs matter read the overview and, if you think need the surrogacy consultation, contact us to discuss every detail you should know about it.
Read more: Surrogacy in Iran
